Piqua logged 282 home sales over the past twelve months, and the typical one closed near $181,000. A brick ranch with a backyard pool at 3241 Sioux Drive in Indian Ridge cleared that mark by two-thirds, closing at $302,000 after 24 days.

A Brick Ranch Closes Above Asking in Indian Ridge
The brick ranch at 3241 Sioux Drive in Piqua’s Indian Ridge subdivision closed on November 12, 2026 for $302,000, $2,000 over its $300,000 list price. That is a margin of 0.7 percent, small on paper, but it matters in a market where plenty of sellers are negotiating down. This home went the other direction, and it did so in 24 days on the market.
The house is a three-bedroom, two-bath single-story home with 1,726 square feet, built in 2000 by Buckeye Builders. At $175 per square foot, it sold well above the Piqua median of $133 per square foot. Behind the house sit a 33-by-18-foot swimming pool, two storage sheds and a fenced .44-acre lot with mature trees.
Taken together, the numbers put this sale in good company. Across 282 Piqua sales in the last twelve months, $302,000 ranks 46th, which places it among the strongest closings the city has recorded in that stretch. The highest sale in the same period was $550,000, so the top of the market has real room above this price, and a home like this one sits comfortably in the upper tier.
What follows is the story of how a 26-year-old brick ranch earned that placement: the systems that were replaced this year, the one-level layout, the outdoor setup, and the way the price compares with the homes that sold around it.

One-Level Living on Nearly Half an Acre
The listing describes the home as comfortable one-level living with an open layout, and the numbers support that. 1,726 square feet on a single floor is a generous footprint for a three-bedroom house. Nothing in the layout asks a buyer to climb stairs to reach a bedroom, and with two full baths the house works for a household that wants a bathroom close to the bedrooms without sharing one across the whole house.
The living area is anchored by a gas fireplace with a blower. A blower matters more than it sounds: it moves heat out into the room instead of leaving the warmth at the hearth, which turns a decorative feature into a working one during an Ohio winter. Fresh interior paint, applied in 2026, gives the rooms a clean, neutral starting point, and the carpet was replaced in 2024.
The kitchen carries its updates openly. Flooring, range, refrigerator, dishwasher and garbage disposal were all replaced in 2020 and 2021, and a new microwave went in during 2025. Both bathrooms were updated as well. For a buyer, that means the rooms that usually generate the longest renovation lists in a house of this age are already addressed.
Outside, the home sits on a .44-acre lot, roughly two and a half times the size of the typical quarter-acre suburban parcel. The lot has mature trees and black metal fencing installed in 2022. An attached two-car garage handles daily parking, and two large storage sheds take the overflow: lawn equipment, tools, seasonal gear. In a house at this price point, that much covered storage is a real part of the value, because it keeps the garage available for vehicles.

The 2026 Mechanical Updates
The first thing the listing calls out is a trio of new systems: a new furnace, central air and water heater, all installed in 2026. These are the three components that most often drive a buyer’s inspection concerns and a lender’s questions on a home built around the turn of the century. At 26 years old, the house was at the age where original equipment is typically due for replacement. Having all three replaced in the same year effectively resets the clock on the most expensive mechanical items in the house.
That timing is part of why the sale moved quickly. A buyer touring a home with new heating, cooling and hot water does not have to build a replacement fund into the monthly budget or negotiate credits after an inspection. The home also came with a one-year home warranty, which adds a layer of protection in the first twelve months of ownership and gives a purchaser a clear point of contact if something unexpected comes up.
The listing also notes immediate occupancy. For buyers coming from a sale of their own, or those who want to close and move without a gap, a vacant, ready house shortens the timeline. The sale closed on November 12, after just 24 days on the market, a little under the Piqua median of 27 days. The house did not sit, and it did not need a price cut to move.
The update list reads like a schedule of maintenance done on time. Kitchen appliances in 2020 and 2021, a pool motor in 2025, a microwave in 2025, carpet in 2024, fencing in 2022, and then the furnace, air conditioning, water heater and paint in 2026. Buyers can read that sequence as a sign of consistent upkeep, and the price reflects it.

The Pool, the Sheds and a Yard Built for Use
The most distinctive feature of 3241 Sioux Drive is in the backyard. The listing describes a professionally installed swimming pool measuring 33 by 18 feet, which comes to 594 square feet of water surface. The pool motor was replaced in 2025, and the pool equipment stays with the house.
Because the sale closed in mid-November, the seller’s arrangement is practical: the seller agreed to winterize the pool and to help with the spring opening if the new owner wants it. That is a meaningful offer for anyone who has not owned a pool before, since opening and closing are the two points in the year when inexperience gets expensive. The buyer takes a pool that is already closed for the season, with the person who knows its quirks available when it is time to open it.
The fenced lot makes the pool easier to use. Black metal fencing, installed in 2022, encloses the yard and gives the property a defined edge without blocking the view of the mature trees. Two large sheds add storage for pool supplies, mowers and outdoor equipment, and the attached two-car garage keeps vehicles under cover.
A pool is not a feature every buyer wants, and it does not necessarily add dollar-for-dollar value in a Midwest market. What it does is narrow the field to buyers who want exactly this, and a house with a pool, a fenced half-acre and fresh mechanicals gives those buyers few reasons to hesitate. The result here was a sale above list in under four weeks.

How $302,000 Compares With the Piqua Market
Over the past twelve months, Piqua recorded 282 sales. The median sale price was $181,000, the median price per square foot was $133, and the median home spent 27 days on the market. Against those figures, 3241 Sioux Drive sits well above center: $121,000 more than the median price, or 67 percent above it.
The per-square-foot comparison is the more telling one, because it accounts for size. At $175 per square foot, this home closed about 32 percent above the city’s median of $133. A larger house will often have a lower price per square foot, so a premium on that measure suggests buyers were paying for condition and extras rather than just room.
In rank terms, the sale was 46th of 282. That puts it inside the top 17 percent of Piqua sales over the period. The top sale was $550,000, and a market that reaches that level while also producing a steady run of sales above $300,000 is one with a healthy upper tier.
The days-on-market figure completes the picture. A house selling for 67 percent above the median could reasonably take longer to find its buyer, since the pool of purchasers at that price is smaller. Instead it moved in 24 days, ahead of the 27-day median, and it closed above list. That pairing of a high price and a short wait is the signal worth noting.
The Closest Comparables
The most recent sales near 3241 Sioux Drive are a useful reference, though most of them are smaller homes at lower price points. The closest in scale is a four-bedroom house on Washington Avenue that closed on November 17, 2026 for $210,000. It offers 2,413 square feet, about 700 square feet more than the Sioux Drive home, yet it sold for $92,000 less, at roughly $87 per square foot against Sioux Drive’s $175. The two homes show how much a buyer’s premium can depend on condition, systems and outdoor amenities, not just size.
A three-bedroom on Willard Street, which closed on November 18 for $160,000, matches the bedroom count at 1,023 square feet. It sold for about $156 per square foot, so on a per-foot basis it was closer to Sioux Drive than the larger Washington Avenue house was. Even so, the Sioux Drive home delivered roughly 700 more square feet and the extra bathroom, the garage, the pool and the lot, for $142,000 more.
The remaining recent sales were two-bedroom homes. A 805-square-foot house on Boal Avenue closed for $133,500 on November 19, and a 1,080-square-foot house on W North Street sold for $107,000 on November 17. These are different products for different buyers, and they underline how much range exists in Piqua’s market. A buyer at $302,000 is in a distinct segment, competing for move-in-ready, larger single-story homes with updates rather than for the smaller starter inventory.
That segmentation is good news for owners in Indian Ridge. A sale at this level, completed above asking and quickly, shows the market has depth beyond the entry tier, and it gives appraisers a current, well-documented point of reference for other three-bedroom brick ranches in the subdivision.
What the Sale Means for Indian Ridge and Piqua
One sale does not set the direction of a city, but it adds evidence to a pattern. When a home built in 2000 closes at $302,000, above list, after 24 days, it tells owners of similar homes in Indian Ridge that well-maintained houses with current systems can command a clear premium. It tells prospective sellers that investment in a new furnace, air conditioning and water heater, along with fresh paint, can pay off at the closing table.
The sale also tells buyers something. In a city where the median is $181,000, there is a segment of the market where homes cost more, take less time to sell and come with substantial extras. Buyers who want a pool, a fenced yard and a one-level plan will find them at a price well above the median, but one that the market has just shown it will support.
For Piqua more broadly, a sale ranking 46th of 282 is part of a market that has produced homes at $550,000 and homes at $73,000 within the same stretch of time. That breadth is useful. A city where the top end is moving and the entry level remains accessible gives owners room to move up and newcomers room to move in.
For 3241 Sioux Drive, the next chapter is a spring pool opening, with the seller’s help if needed. The previous owner kept the house current for years, replaced its major systems this year and handed it over closed for winter. The sale price reflects that care, and it adds a fresh, strong number to the record for Indian Ridge.
Recognizing the Professionals Behind the Outcome
Patty Murphy of Coldwell Banker Heritage represented both the seller and the buyer on this sale. Results like this come from careful pricing, strong presentation and steady work through closing, and that work deserves recognition.
Listing data courtesy of Dayton REALTORS® MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
More Common Questions About Piqua
Here are answers to practical questions about this sale and the Piqua housing market.
How much did 3241 Sioux Drive sell for?
The home sold for $302,000 on November 12, 2026. It was listed at $300,000, so it closed $2,000, or 0.7 percent, above asking after 24 days on the market.
What kind of home is it?
It is a brick ranch in Piqua’s Indian Ridge subdivision with 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths and 1,726 square feet on one level. It was built in 2000 and sits on a .44-acre lot with an attached two-car garage, two storage sheds, a fenced yard and a 33-by-18-foot swimming pool.
How does the price compare with the typical Piqua sale?
Piqua’s median sale price over the past twelve months is $181,000, so this sale came in 67 percent above it. At $175 per square foot, it also compares with a city median of $133 per square foot. Among 282 Piqua sales in that period, it ranks 46th.
What was updated in the home?
A new furnace, central air and water heater were installed in 2026, and the interior was repainted that year. Carpet was replaced in 2024, the microwave in 2025, and the kitchen flooring, range, refrigerator, dishwasher and disposal in 2020 and 2021. Both bathrooms were updated, and the pool motor was replaced in 2025.
Does the sale include anything for the pool?
Yes. The pool equipment stays with the home, and the seller agreed to winterize the pool and help with the spring opening if needed. A one-year home warranty was also included.
How fast do homes typically sell in Piqua?
The median time on market in Piqua over the past twelve months is 27 days. This home sold in 24 days, slightly faster than the median, even though it closed at a price well above it.
Follow Dayton Report: Facebook · X · Get the Dayton weekend email
