• About WordPress
    • WordPress.org
    • Documentation
    • Learn WordPress
    • Support
    • Feedback
  • Log In
  • Edit Home Page
Skip to content

Dayton Report

Local Stories. Real People. Stronger Community.

Menu
  • News
    • Public meetings
    • Business & economy
    • Election results
    • All sections
  • Real Estate
    • Open houses
    • Realtor leaderboards
    • Housing market
    • Home values map
    • Sheriff sales
  • Business
    • New & coming soon
    • Jobs board
    • What’s being built
    • Business indicators
    • Add your business
  • Things to Do
    • Christmas lights
    • This weekend
    • Free things to do
    • With kids
    • Date night
    • Outdoors & parks
  • Live Here
    • Church finder
    • Guides
    • Rental help
    • Food pantries
    • Moving to Dayton
    • Snow & school closings
  • Sports
  • Tools & Data
    • Look up my address
    • My Area
    • Paycheck calculator
    • Property tax calculator
    • Utilities by address
    • ZIP code map
    • All free tools →
    • Housing market
    • Cost of living
    • Jobs & economy
    • Population
    • Schools map
    • Weather
    • All data →
  • Subscribe
Menu
Living room with hardwood floors, walls of glass and a brick fireplace

9777 Wolf Creek Pike Sells for $510,000, Setting a New Ceiling for Trotwood

Posted on November 18, 2026November 18, 2026 by Dayton Report

West Dayton’s momentum shows up in the details: homes that sell quickly, sell over list and keep raising the top of the comp range. At 9777 Wolf Creek Pike, a brick ranch on more than six acres in Trotwood closed at $510,000, the highest sale in the area in the past 12 months.

Brick ranch home at 9777 Wolf Creek Pike in Trotwood, set among trees on more than six acres

A $510,000 Sale That Raises the Ceiling in Trotwood

Every neighborhood has a price it has not yet reached, and then one day a house closes above it. In Trotwood, that day was November 17, 2026, when 9777 Wolf Creek Pike sold for $510,000. The property is a brick ranch on more than six acres, with a working horse barn behind the house and a city park along the back boundary.

The home was listed at $469,000. It closed $41,000 above that number, which is 8.7% over list, and it needed only 3 days on the market to get there. The typical Trotwood home sold over the past 12 months took 30 days. This one moved in a tenth of that time and still drew a price well past what it was marketed at.

Among the 207 Trotwood sales recorded over the past 12 months, this is the highest. It ranks 1 of 207 and sets a new ceiling for the area. No other closing in that stretch reached $510,000.

West Dayton’s recent story has been told one closing at a time, and every sale that clears its list price adds to the case that buyer demand here is broad rather than narrow. This one adds a data point at the very top of the range, in a part of the market where nothing had closed at this level in a full year.

A result like this does not happen by accident. It takes a property with an uncommon combination of land, privacy, outbuildings and documented upkeep, and 9777 Wolf Creek Pike had all four.

Deck at the back of the brick ranch overlooking the yard and trees

More Than 6.5 Acres With a Park at the Back Property Line

The setting is the first thing to understand about this sale. The house sits at the end of a drive off a quiet country road, a brick ranch set back among trees on more than 6.5 acres. From the road, the house is part of the landscape rather than the focal point of a lot.

Sycamore Park borders the back of the property. In practical terms, that means no rear neighbors. Behind the house there is open pasture and a stand of tall pines, and beyond them there is park rather than another backyard. For a buyer who wants distance and quiet while staying inside the Dayton area, that kind of boundary is hard to replicate.

Acreage like this is the reason the price cannot be read against a typical Trotwood sale. The buyer is paying for land, privacy and outbuildings as much as for a house, and a comparison against the neighborhood median only goes so far. Where the comparison does work, it shows how much more property this was than the usual Trotwood closing, which later sections lay out in numbers.

The listing description leans on the feeling of the place: slow mornings on the deck, sunsets, room to spread out. Strip away the language and the facts underneath are specific and measurable. There are six and a half acres, a park at the back line, a fenced yard area for pets and a barn with water and electricity. Those features are what a buyer could count on after closing.

Finished walkout lower level opening to the covered patio

Inside the Brick Ranch: Glass, Hardwood and a Walkout Lower Level

The house itself is a brick ranch built in 1970, with four bedrooms, three full baths and 3,915 square feet. That is a large footprint for a single-story-style layout, and it is the reason the sale price, big as it is, works out to a more modest figure per square foot.

The main living space is organized around hardwood floors, walls of glass that bring daylight deep into the rooms, and a brick fireplace that anchors the living area. A deck extends from the back of the house toward the trees and pasture, which turns the view of the property into part of the daily routine rather than something to look at through a window.

Below the main level is a finished walkout lower level that opens directly to a covered patio and the yard. A walkout is different from an ordinary basement: it has grade-level access and natural light, so the space can function as a second living area for gatherings, game days or holidays. The listing describes it in just those terms, as room for a crowd.

The home also carries dated improvements that a buyer can verify rather than guess at. The main bath was updated in 2019 with a heated tile floor and a Bath Fitter shower. All-new appliances went in during 2023, which means the kitchen equipment was only a few years old at the time of sale. A hot tub was added in 2020, and a fenced pet playground in 2019.

Taken together, that is a house where the major comfort items had been refreshed in the years leading up to the listing. The price reflects the square footage and the setting, but it also reflects that a buyer could move in without immediately scheduling the usual first-year replacements.

Main bath with heated tile floor and updated shower

The Barn, the Boiler and the Updates Behind the Price

For buyers with horses, or buyers who simply want a working outbuilding, the barn is the second half of this property. It measures 30 by 40 feet and includes two stalls. Each stall opens to its own 20 by 40 turnout, so the animals have outdoor space attached directly to their shelter. The barn also has a tack room, a hay loft and an electric hoist, and it is supplied with both electricity and water.

Those details separate a real horse setup from a shed with a gate. Electricity and water in the barn matter every day, and so does a hay loft with a hoist that saves labor during feeding and storage. On a six-and-a-half-acre parcel with pasture, the barn turns the land from scenery into usable property.

The water arrangement is worth spelling out. City water serves the house itself. Well water supplies the outdoor faucets and the barn. That split keeps the household on a municipal supply while giving the outdoor and animal needs their own source. The well has a new pump installed in 2018, a dated update that speaks to the maintenance of the system.

Heat is the most distinctive system on the property. In 2021, an outdoor boiler was installed, a wood-fired unit that sits outside the house and heats the entire home. The listing says the seller has fed it firewood through the coldest months and considers it remarkably efficient. For a buyer comfortable with firewood and the routine that comes with it, that is a notable feature on acreage with trees. For anyone new to an outdoor boiler, the seller’s experience is the thing to ask about.

Add the year-by-year list together and the pattern is clear: a new well pump in 2018, a bath update and a fenced pet playground in 2019, a hot tub in 2020, the boiler in 2021 and new appliances in 2023. A buyer looking at a home built in 1970 gets a documented record of reinvestment, which gives the $510,000 number something solid to stand on.

30 by 40 horse barn with turnouts, pasture and tall pines behind the house

How $510,000 Stacks Up Against the Trotwood Market

Trotwood’s median sale price over the past 12 months was $150,000 across 207 sales. At $510,000, this sale came in 240% above that median, which is a gap of $360,000. It is also the highest closing of the 207, ranking 1 of 207 in the neighborhood and standing as the area record for the period.

The more revealing number is the price per square foot. This home sold at $130 per square foot. The Trotwood median is $109. That puts this sale roughly 19% above the median per foot, a far smaller premium than the 240% gap on total price. In plain terms, most of the distance between $150,000 and $510,000 comes from size and land, not from an extraordinary rate per square foot.

That is a healthy way for a record to happen. A buyer paid a rate that sits reasonably near what the neighborhood sees, on a house of 3,915 square feet that is far larger than the typical Trotwood home, with more than 6.5 acres and a barn added to the package. The record exists because the property was so much bigger than anything else that sold, not because the market stretched on a per-foot basis.

The speed of the sale tells a similar story. The median Trotwood home in the past 12 months took 30 days to sell. This one took 3. A typical home is a sale that unfolds over a month, and this property cleared in less time than it takes many listings to schedule their first round of showings.

It also sold above its asking price. The list price of $469,000 was already more than three times the neighborhood median, and buyers still pushed the final number up by $41,000. When a home priced at that level draws a result above list in three days, it signals that the buyer pool for acreage properties in the area is real, even if it is a small pool.

What Nearby Closings Show

Five Trotwood-area sales closed in the days just before this one, between November 6 and November 16, 2026, and they illustrate how far this property sat from the usual transaction. Prices on those five ranged from $72,000 to $225,000.

The closest comparison by bedroom count is a four-bedroom home on Olive Tree Drive that sold on November 13 for $225,000. It measures 2,571 square feet, which works out to roughly $88 per square foot. The Wolf Creek Pike house has 1,344 more square feet and sold for $285,000 more, more than twice that price. Both are four-bedroom houses, but the acreage, the barn and the lower level put them in different categories.

On November 16, a two-bedroom home on Old Dayton Road closed at $190,000 with 1,310 square feet. A three-bedroom on Hillgard Street, with 1,479 square feet, sold at $153,000 on November 13. Those two sit near the neighborhood’s typical price band, and they show what a conventional Trotwood sale looked like the same week this record closed.

The gap between those prices and $510,000 is the point. A house like 9777 Wolf Creek Pike does not have a direct neighbor in the sales data, so it set its own mark. For the next owner of acreage in Trotwood who decides to sell, there is now a closing to point to, along with the features that drove it: land, a park boundary, a barn with utilities and a recent run of updates.

What the Sale Means for Trotwood and West Dayton

The headline for West Dayton has been steady for a while: sales that confirm demand, one transaction after another. A $510,000 closing in Trotwood adds a different kind of confirmation. It shows that buyers are active at the top of the local range as well as in the more affordable tiers, and that they will compete for a property that offers something the usual listing does not.

This sale also shows the value of a well-documented home. Listing agents often talk about condition and presentation, and here the details were dated: 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2023. A buyer evaluating a 1970 house could see what had been replaced and when. In a market that rewards clarity, that helps a seller hold a price.

It matters for Trotwood as a whole, too. Neighborhood medians drift upward when the top of the market moves, and appraisers and lenders look at the highest recent comps when they evaluate unusual properties. With a closing at $510,000 on the record, the range of what can be financed and appraised in the area is wider than it was a month ago.

One sale does not remake a neighborhood. But a brick ranch on more than six acres, with a park behind it and a barn ready for horses, went under contract in three days and closed over list, and that is a fair description of momentum. In Trotwood, the ceiling now sits at $510,000.

Recognizing the Professionals Behind the Outcome

Listing agent David Moyer of Keller Williams Advisors Realty brought the home to market, and Jeannie Fudge of Coldwell Banker Heritage represented the buyer. Results like this come from careful pricing, strong presentation and steady work through closing, and both sides of the deal deserve recognition.

Listing data courtesy of Dayton REALTORS® MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Related guides: How a $200,000 Home Is Taxed Across the Miami Valley · Miami Valley home values, on a map

More Common Questions About Trotwood

These are the practical questions readers ask most about this sale and the Trotwood housing market.

How much did 9777 Wolf Creek Pike sell for?

The home sold for $510,000 on November 17, 2026. It was listed at $469,000, so it closed $41,000, or 8.7%, above the asking price.

How does the sale compare with the typical Trotwood home?

The median sale price in Trotwood over the past 12 months was $150,000 across 207 sales, so this sale came in 240% above the median. It was the highest of the 207 sales, which makes it the area high for that period. On a per-square-foot basis the gap is much smaller: $130 for this home versus a neighborhood median of $109.

How quickly did the home sell?

It sold after 3 days on the market. The median Trotwood home over the past 12 months took 30 days.

What is on the property?

The brick ranch was built in 1970 and has four bedrooms, three full baths and 3,915 square feet, including a finished walkout lower level. The lot is more than 6.5 acres and borders Sycamore Park at the back. A 30 by 40 barn has two stalls with 20 by 40 turnouts, a tack room, a hay loft, an electric hoist, electricity and water.

How is the home heated, and what is the water setup?

A wood-fired outdoor boiler installed in 2021 heats the whole home. City water serves the house, while well water supplies the outdoor faucets and the barn. The well received a new pump in 2018.

What updates did the home have before the sale?

The listing lists a new well pump in 2018, a main bath with a heated tile floor and a Bath Fitter shower in 2019, a fenced pet playground in 2019, a hot tub in 2020, the outdoor boiler in 2021 and all-new appliances in 2023.

Share:FacebookXLinkedInNextdoorEmail

Follow Dayton Report: Facebook · X · Get the Dayton weekend email

Dayton Report
Author: Dayton Report

Follow Dayton Report on Facebook and X

Recent Posts

  • 9748 Old Dayton Road Sells for $190,000, 27% Above the Trotwood Median
  • Game day: Miami men’s basketball hosts Defiance, 7 p.m.
  • 9777 Wolf Creek Pike Sells for $510,000, Setting a New Ceiling for Trotwood
  • Game day: Wright State women’s basketball hosts Marshall, 5 p.m.
  • Dayton-area college results, Tuesday, November 17: 2 results from Miami, Cedarville

News

  • Latest News
  • All Sections
  • Public Meetings
  • Election Results
  • Zoning Alerts
  • Sports

Local Guides

  • Things to Do
  • This Weekend
  • Christmas Lights
  • Guides
  • Moving to Dayton
  • School Closings
  • Snow Emergencies
  • Rental Help
  • Food Pantries

Data and Maps

  • Dayton's Data
  • Home Sales
  • Look Up My Address
  • ZIP Code Map
  • Weather
  • Jobs
  • Free Tools

Shop and Community

  • Book Store
  • Church Finder
  • Business Directory
  • Add Your Business
  • Open Houses
  • Realtor Leaderboards

About

  • About
  • Newsletter
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • How We Report
  • Ethics
  • Corrections
  • Privacy
  • RSS Feeds
  • Facebook
  • X
Get Dayton Report by EmailNew local stories, at most one email a day. Free.

©2026 Dayton Report | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme
Change Location
Find awesome listings near you!