West Dayton’s housing market keeps building its record one closing at a time, and Trotwood is a steady part of that story. The latest data point is 9748 Old Dayton Road, a 1947 two-bedroom on 0.74 acres that sold for $190,000, well above the neighborhood median.

A Trotwood Sale in the Top Third of the Year
The house at 9748 Old Dayton Road in Trotwood closed on November 16, 2026 for $190,000. It came to market at $205,000, spent 33 days on the market, and went to a buyer who wanted a 1947 two-bedroom home with real room around it: 0.74 acres, a detached three-car garage and a straight path to US-35.
The number matters beyond a single address. Over the past 12 months Trotwood recorded 207 sales with a median price of $150,000. At $190,000, this home finished 27 percent above that median and ranked 65th of 207, which places it in the top third of all sales in the neighborhood over that stretch. For a two-bedroom, one-bath house, that is a strong place to land.
It also fits the larger pattern. West Dayton’s comeback is not carried only by new construction or showpiece renovations. It is carried just as much by solid, well-located houses that find buyers at healthy prices, closing after closing. This sale is another example, and the details are worth walking through.

What the Buyer Got: 1,310 Square Feet and Room to Spread Out
The home offers two bedrooms, one full bath and 1,310 square feet of living space. It was built in 1947. The listing described it as a charming home with plenty of potential for a new owner to make it their own, language that invites the next chapter of updates rather than promising a finished showpiece.
At the closing price, the home works out to $145 per square foot. The Trotwood median over the last 12 months is $109 per square foot, so this sale came in roughly a third above the typical rate. That gap is the more telling number of the two, because it strips out size. A smaller house can post a modest total price and still be a strong result, and a larger one can post a big total and merely keep pace. Here, a mid-sized home beat the neighborhood’s per-square-foot norm by a wide margin.
A two-bedroom plan on 1,310 square feet leaves more of the footprint for common space than a house of the same size divided into three or four bedrooms. For buyers who care more about the living area than the bedroom count, that is a practical layout. The listing pointed to exactly that kind of audience: first-time buyers, people looking to downsize, and anyone who wants space both inside and out.
A 1947 build date places the house in the postwar years, and the listing’s emphasis on potential speaks to the buyer who sees a solid starting point and plans to put in their own improvements over time. That approach is a familiar one across West Dayton, where owner-occupants buying and improving homes at a steady pace add up to stability on the block.

Acreage and a Three-Car Garage Set This Property Apart
The feature that separates 9748 Old Dayton Road from most houses of its size is the land. The lot measures approximately 0.74 acres, which is roughly 32,000 square feet. The listing described it as a spacious lot with room to spread out, and the number backs that up. For a buyer, that much ground means options: space for a garden, room for outdoor projects, distance from the neighbors, or simply a yard that does not feel like an afterthought.
The second headline feature is the three-car detached garage. The listing framed it as extra parking or storage, and both uses are easy to picture. Three bays of covered space is a rare combination with a two-bedroom house. It gives a household room for vehicles, tools, seasonal gear or a hobby setup without crowding the home itself. Buyers who have outgrown a one-car garage or a gravel pad tend to notice that immediately.
Location rounds out the pitch. The listing highlighted convenient access to US-35, which makes the drive to Dayton and the surrounding area straightforward while the property itself keeps a more relaxed, less crowded setting. That balance, easy commuting with a bit of breathing room, is a large part of what draws buyers to Trotwood in the first place.
Taken together, the acreage, the garage and the highway access explain why a 1,310-square-foot, one-bath house drew a price well above the neighborhood’s middle. Buyers are paying for the whole package of home, land and location, not just the interior square footage.

Where $190,000 Sits in the Trotwood Numbers
The neighborhood-wide figures give this sale its context. Across the last 12 months, Trotwood saw 207 closed sales. The median price was $150,000, the median price per square foot was $109, and the median time on market was 30 days. The highest sale in that window was $510,000, which shows how wide the neighborhood’s market runs, from entry-level homes to large properties at more than three times the median.
Measured against those markers, 9748 Old Dayton Road did well on price. Its $190,000 closing sits $40,000 above the median, 27 percent higher, and its rank of 65 out of 207 means that more than two-thirds of Trotwood’s sales over the period closed for less. Its $145 price per square foot beat the neighborhood’s $109 median by about 33 percent.
On timing, the home took 33 days to sell, close to the neighborhood’s 30-day median. A property that moves in about a month, at a price well above the middle of the market, is a healthy outcome. It suggests buyers saw the value in the land and the garage and were willing to pay for it.
The list-to-sale path was also straightforward. The home was listed at $205,000 and closed at $190,000, a difference of 7.3 percent. The final figure still cleared the neighborhood median by a comfortable margin, and the sale finished in about the time a typical Trotwood home takes to find its buyer.

Reading the Closest Comparable Sales
Several sales closed in Trotwood within days of this one, and the closest comparisons by size and price help show what the market is paying for.
On November 13, 2026, a three-bedroom home on Hillgard Street with 1,479 square feet sold for $153,000. That house is about 170 square feet larger than 9748 Old Dayton Road and has an extra bedroom, yet it closed $37,000 lower, at roughly $103 per square foot. The difference in price per square foot, $145 versus $103, points straight at the property features that Hillgard Street did not advertise in this comparison: the 0.74-acre lot and the three-car garage.
The same day, a four-bedroom home on Olive Tree Drive with 2,571 square feet sold for $225,000. That is nearly twice the living space of the Old Dayton Road house for just $35,000 more, or about $88 per square foot. It is a useful reminder that buyers in this market weigh several things at once, and that a smaller home with land and outbuildings can command a stronger rate per square foot than a larger home on a standard lot.
At the top of the range, a four-bedroom, 3,915-square-foot home on Wolf Creek Pike closed on November 17, 2026, the day after the Old Dayton Road sale, for $510,000. That is the highest sale in Trotwood’s 12-month window, and it works out to about $130 per square foot. Even there, the Old Dayton Road sale at $145 per square foot held its own on a rate basis.
The wider set of recent closings in the neighborhood includes smaller homes at much lower prices, which is part of why the neighborhood median sits at $150,000. Against that spread, a $190,000 sale for a two-bedroom house is a clear mid-to-upper result, and four closings between November 13 and November 17 show steady buyer activity heading into the end of the year.
Thirty-Three Days From Listing to Closing Day
The timeline of the sale is simple. The home went on the market at $205,000, and 33 days later it had a buyer at $190,000, with the sale recorded on November 16, 2026. In a neighborhood where the median home takes 30 days to sell, that is a normal pace for a property with distinctive features.
Pricing a home with acreage and a large garage can be hard, because few comparable sales offer the same combination. Neither the Hillgard Street sale nor the Olive Tree Drive sale had both the lot and the garage, so appraisers and agents have to adjust from several directions at once. A sale at $145 per square foot tells future sellers where a buyer was willing to meet the market for this particular mix of features.
That is useful information for anyone considering a similar property in Trotwood. A two-bedroom home with a large lot and a multi-car garage found its price in about a month. It did so in a neighborhood with 207 sales in the past year, which means the market has enough activity to produce meaningful signals about what buyers are paying.
What the Sale Means for Trotwood and West Dayton
Every closed sale becomes part of the record that the next buyer, seller, lender and appraiser will use. A $190,000 sale for a 1,310-square-foot, two-bedroom home on 0.74 acres with a three-car garage adds a clear data point for properties that offer more land than the typical house. It shows that buyers in Trotwood will pay above the neighborhood median when a home offers something the standard lot cannot.
That matters for homeowners who are thinking about their own property. Owners with outbuildings, larger yards or extra garage space now have a recent local result that points to how the market values those features. It matters for buyers, too, since it shows that Trotwood still offers a range of home types and lot sizes at prices well under what many other parts of the region would ask.
It also fits the broader West Dayton story. Trotwood sits within a West Dayton market where steady buyer demand, owner-occupant purchases and a wide range of price points are all visible in the numbers. With 207 sales over 12 months, a $150,000 median and a market that stretches from modest starter homes to a $510,000 sale on Wolf Creek Pike, the neighborhood shows depth, not a single narrow band of activity.
The lesson from 9748 Old Dayton Road is a plain one. A well-located house with land, a big garage and room for a new owner’s improvements found its buyer in about a month, at a price in the top third of the neighborhood’s sales. That is the kind of result that builds confidence block by block, and it is a good sign heading into the new year.
Recognizing the Professionals Behind the Outcome
Listing agent Ashleigh Croft of Irongate, Inc. brought the home to market, and Billie Duncan-Hart of Coldwell Banker Heritage represented the buyer. Results like this come from careful pricing, strong presentation and steady work through closing, and both sides of the deal deserve recognition.
Listing data courtesy of Dayton REALTORS® MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
More Common Questions About Trotwood
Here are answers to some practical questions about this sale and the Trotwood housing market.
How much did 9748 Old Dayton Road sell for?
The home sold for $190,000 on November 16, 2026. It was listed at $205,000 and spent 33 days on the market before closing.
How does the sale price compare with the Trotwood median?
Over the last 12 months, Trotwood recorded 207 sales with a median price of $150,000. At $190,000, this home sold 27 percent above that median and ranked 65th of the 207 sales.
What are the key features of the home?
The home was built in 1947 and has two bedrooms, one full bath and 1,310 square feet of living space. It sits on approximately 0.74 acres and includes a three-car detached garage, with convenient access to US-35.
What was the price per square foot?
The sale worked out to about $145 per square foot. The Trotwood median over the last 12 months is $109 per square foot.
How long do homes typically take to sell in Trotwood?
The median time on market in Trotwood over the last 12 months was 30 days. This home sold in 33 days, close to the neighborhood’s typical pace.
What other homes sold nearby around the same time?
A three-bedroom, 1,479-square-foot home on Hillgard Street sold for $153,000 on November 13, 2026. A four-bedroom, 2,571-square-foot home on Olive Tree Drive sold for $225,000 the same day, and a four-bedroom, 3,915-square-foot home on Wolf Creek Pike sold for $510,000 on November 17, 2026.
Follow Dayton Report: Facebook · X · Get the Dayton weekend email
