• About WordPress
    • WordPress.org
    • Documentation
    • Learn WordPress
    • Support
    • Feedback
  • Log In
  • Edit Home Page
Skip to content

Dayton Report

Local Stories. Real People. Stronger Community.

Menu
  • News
    • Public meetings
    • Business & economy
    • All sections
  • Real Estate
    • Open houses
    • Realtor leaderboards
    • Housing market
    • Home values map
    • Sheriff sales
  • Business
    • New & coming soon
    • Jobs board
    • What’s being built
    • Business indicators
    • Add your business
  • Things to Do
    • Christmas lights
    • This weekend
    • Free things to do
    • With kids
    • Date night
    • Outdoors & parks
  • Live Here
    • Church finder
    • Guides
    • Rental help
    • Food pantries
    • Moving to Dayton
    • Snow & school closings
  • Sports
  • Tools & Data
    • Look up my address
    • My Area
    • Paycheck calculator
    • Property tax calculator
    • Utilities by address
    • ZIP code map
    • All free tools →
    • Housing market
    • Cost of living
    • Jobs & economy
    • Population
    • Schools map
    • Weather
    • All data →
  • Subscribe
Menu
Living room with open loft above and gas fireplace

4093 Wagner Road Sells for $630,000 in 2 Days, a Top-Tier Win for Sugarcreek Township

Posted on November 22, 2026 by Dayton Report Staff

Sugarcreek Township has logged 103 home sales in the past 12 months, and the typical one closed near $379,900. A 2.58-acre property on Wagner Road just sold for $630,000, five percent over its asking price, two days after it hit the market.

Front exterior of the contemporary home at 4093 Wagner Road in Sugarcreek Township

A Full-Price Offer, Then Some, in Two Days

The most telling number in the sale of 4093 Wagner Road is not the $630,000 closing price. It is the 2 days the home spent on the market. In a township where the typical home over the past 12 months took 40 days to sell, this one was spoken for almost as soon as it was listed, and the buyer paid $30,100 more than the $599,900 asking price to make sure of it.

The sale closed on November 17, 2026, and it lands 5.0 percent above list. That is a meaningful premium in any market, and it matters more at this price level, where buyers have the time and the leverage to be selective. A seller who prices at $599,900 and ends up at $630,000 has read the market correctly, and a buyer who moves that fast has recognized something that does not come up often.

Within Sugarcreek Township, the sale ranks 22nd of 103 closed sales over the last 12 months. That places it among the strongest results in the township, well inside the top quarter of everything that has changed hands. The price sits 66 percent above the township median of $379,900, a gap of roughly $250,000.

The house is a contemporary built in 1988, with 3 bedrooms, 3 full baths and 2,765 square feet of living space. But the property is a larger story than the house. It sits on 2.58 acres in the Xenia Reserve Sec 01 subdivision, with a pond, walking paths, woods and a party barn, and the sale price reflects all of it.

Kitchen with granite countertops and ample cabinet storage

2.58 Acres, a Pond and a Barn

Most homes in Sugarcreek Township sell on the strength of the house. This one sold on the strength of the grounds as much as the floor plan. The listing describes meandering walking paths that wind through the property and its woods, and a fish-stocked pond that anchors the back of the lot. Across 2.58 acres, that is a lot of ground for a single household to have to itself.

A deck looks out over the grounds, and an enclosed porch gives the house a second place to sit outside when the weather turns. The listing pitches the porch as a way to enjoy every season, which is a practical point: a porch with walls and a roof gets used in October and April, not just in July.

Then there is the party barn. The listing calls it a place for entertaining or added storage, and the dual purpose is the real value. A detached building of that kind can host a gathering one weekend and hold equipment, tools or seasonal gear the next. On a property this size, an outbuilding turns from a nice extra into something that changes how the land can be used.

The garage deserves its own mention. The home has an oversized three-car heated garage with a work area. Heated space matters in an Ohio winter, and the work area means the garage is more than parking. For a buyer who works on vehicles, builds things or simply wants a place to keep projects going all year, that is a feature that is hard to find attached to a house, let alone one on this much land.

The listing frames the setting as country living without giving up nearby conveniences, and it points to an easy commute as part of the appeal. The facts on file do not specify distances, so the useful takeaway is simply how the seller chose to market it: privacy and space, with the daily routine still within reach.

Enclosed porch and deck overlooking the wooded grounds

Inside: A Dramatic Living Room and a Loft Above

The layout is built around a dramatic living room that a loft overlooks. That is a hallmark of contemporary design from the era, where open vertical space gives a room scale that square footage alone does not. Two gas fireplaces add warmth to the interior, which gives the house more than one focal point on a cold evening.

The kitchen is described as beautifully appointed, with granite countertops, generous workspace and abundant storage. In a home of 2,765 square feet that is likely to host gatherings, given the party barn and the deck, counter space and storage are not details. They decide whether a kitchen can keep up with the way the rest of the property is used.

The house has three bedrooms and three full bathrooms, a ratio that gives every bedroom easy access to a bath. Walk-in closets are listed among the highlights, a feature that tends to matter more in a house of this size than the bedroom count alone suggests.

Recent flooring work adds to the picture. The listing notes new carpet installed in 2025 and luxury vinyl plank flooring installed in 2026. That means a buyer is not walking into a house that needs its floors redone, and the 2026 work is recent enough that it was completed in the same year as the sale.

The overall picture is a home with architectural character, meaning the loft, the tall living room and the fireplaces, paired with finishes that have been kept current. That combination is part of why a house from 1988 could bring $228 per square foot.

Fish-stocked pond and walking path on the 2.58-acre property

The Update List Behind the Price

A property on this much land has a lot to maintain, and buyers at this price point look closely at what has already been done. The listing includes a specific timeline of improvements, and each item is dated.

The roof was replaced in 2019. The furnace dates to 2021. The AC and heat pump is a hybrid system installed in 2024. A new electronic air cleaner went in during 2026. Add the carpet from 2025 and the vinyl plank flooring from 2026, and the major systems and surfaces all fall within roughly the last seven years.

For a home built in 1988, that is the difference between a house that is thirty-some years old and one that has been kept current. The roof and the heating and cooling equipment are among the largest expenses an owner faces, and having them replaced on a documented schedule takes much of the uncertainty out of the purchase.

It also helps explain the speed of the sale. A buyer looking at a property with a pond, a barn, woods and a heated three-car garage is already thinking about upkeep of the grounds. Knowing the roof, the furnace and the heat pump are in good order frees that buyer to focus on the land rather than the mechanicals.

The listing describes an impressive list of updates and quality improvements throughout, and the dated items are the part that can be pinned down. They give a buyer, an appraiser and a lender something concrete to work from.

Party barn and oversized heated garage on the grounds

How $630,000 Compares With the Township Numbers

Sugarcreek Township recorded 103 sales in the past 12 months, with a median sale price of $379,900, a median price per square foot of $191 and a median of 40 days on the market. Set against those figures, 4093 Wagner Road sold higher, faster and at a stronger rate per square foot.

At $630,000, the sale is 66 percent above the median price. At $228 per square foot, it is also well above the township median of $191, which matters because it shows the premium is not only about size. Larger homes naturally sell for more dollars, but paying more per square foot means the buyer valued something beyond the floor area. Here, that something is the land, the pond, the barn and the garage.

The days on market are the other half of the story. A median of 40 days means a typical seller waits more than five weeks for an acceptable offer. This one had a closed sale shortly after listing, and at a price that cleared the asking figure by $30,100.

Ranking 22nd of 103 places the sale in the upper tier of the township’s year. That is a strong position for a home that was listed under $600,000, and it speaks to how the market treated a property that does not have many direct comparisons.

The listing calls this a one-of-a-kind property that cannot be duplicated, and the market behaved as if it agreed. When a seller prices a unique property and the first buyers to see it respond with a competitive offer, it is a good sign for how well-presented, well-maintained homes on larger lots are being received.

The Closest Nearby Sales

Recent closed sales nearby give this result some context. The nearest comparison by price and size is a four-bedroom home on Cypress Pointe Drive with 3,036 square feet that sold for $570,000 on November 9, 2026, just over a week before the Wagner Road closing. That works out to roughly $188 per square foot, compared with $228 on Wagner Road. The Wagner Road home has less living space and brought a higher total price.

Another useful reference is a four-bedroom home on State Route 725 with 3,484 square feet that sold for $704,000 on October 8, 2026. That is about $202 per square foot. It is a larger house and a higher total price, but at 4093 Wagner Road the buyer paid more for each square foot of living space, which points again to the weight of the acreage and outbuildings.

Together, those two sales bracket the Wagner Road result. One closed about $60,000 below it, the other about $74,000 above it, and both involved more living space. That puts $630,000 squarely within the range for large, higher-end properties in the area, rather than out on its own.

Closer to the township median, a three-bedroom home with 2,005 square feet on Little Sugar Creek Road sold for $335,000 on October 30, 2026, about $167 per square foot. The difference between that sale and this one shows how wide the township’s housing range is, and how much the combination of land, outbuildings and recent updates can add.

What the Sale Says About Sugarcreek Township

A single closing does not define a township, but it does show what buyers will pay for when the property delivers. In this case, the answer is space, privacy and a property that has been maintained: acreage with a pond, a barn, walking paths, a heated garage and a house with dated, recent improvements to its major systems.

For homeowners elsewhere in Sugarcreek Township, the takeaway is that presentation and preparation are rewarded. A listing with a clear update timeline, a distinctive feature set and a price that reflects the market drew an offer above asking in two days. That is useful information for any owner weighing when and how to list.

For buyers, the sale is a reminder of how the township’s market has layers. The median is $379,900, and many homes sell well under $400,000, but there is also a segment of larger, land-rich properties that move quickly at higher prices. Knowing which segment you are shopping in changes how fast you need to act.

For the area’s appraisers and lenders, the Wagner Road closing adds a data point for acreage properties with outbuildings, a category that is often hard to compare. With 103 sales in 12 months and a median of $379,900, the township has a deep base of ordinary transactions, and each well-documented upper-tier sale helps define what the top of the market looks like.

The closing of 4093 Wagner Road is a good result for the seller, a clear decision by the buyer, and one more sign that Sugarcreek Township’s market rewards homes with something distinctive to offer.

Recognizing the Professionals Behind the Outcome

Listing agent Jennifer J Durbin of Irongate Inc. brought the home to market, and Rhoda E Gazda ABR of Keller Williams Advisors Realty represented the buyer. Results like this come from careful pricing, strong presentation and steady work through closing, and both sides of the deal deserve recognition.

Listing data courtesy of Dayton REALTORS® MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Related guides: How a $200,000 Home Is Taxed Across the Miami Valley · Miami Valley home values, on a map

More Common Questions About Sugarcreek Township

Here are practical answers about this sale and the Sugarcreek Township housing market, based on the closed-sale numbers.

How much did 4093 Wagner Road sell for?

The home sold for $630,000 on November 17, 2026. The list price was $599,900, so it closed $30,100, or 5.0 percent, above asking.

How long was the home on the market?

Just 2 days. The median home in Sugarcreek Township over the past 12 months took 40 days to sell.

How does the sale compare with the typical Sugarcreek Township home?

Over the past 12 months, Sugarcreek Township recorded 103 sales with a median price of $379,900. The Wagner Road sale was 66 percent above that median and ranked 22nd of 103. At $228 per square foot, it also topped the township median of $191.

What are the main features of the property?

It is a 1988 contemporary with 3 bedrooms, 3 full baths and 2,765 square feet, sitting on 2.58 acres in the Xenia Reserve Sec 01 subdivision. The listing highlights a living room with an overlooking loft, two gas fireplaces, a granite kitchen, an enclosed porch, a deck, a party barn, walking paths, a fish-stocked pond and an oversized three-car heated garage with a work area.

What updates had been made to the home?

According to the listing, the roof was replaced in 2019 and the furnace dates to 2021. The hybrid AC and heat pump was installed in 2024, the carpet in 2025, and both the electronic air cleaner and the luxury vinyl plank flooring in 2026.

How do nearby sales compare?

A four-bedroom, 3,036-square-foot home on Cypress Pointe Drive sold for $570,000 on November 9, 2026, about $188 per square foot. A four-bedroom, 3,484-square-foot home on State Route 725 sold for $704,000 on October 8, 2026, about $202 per square foot. The Wagner Road sale came in at $228 per square foot.

Share:FacebookXLinkedInNextdoorEmail

Follow Dayton Report: Facebook · X · Get the Dayton weekend email

Dayton Report Staff
Author: Dayton Report Staff

Follow Dayton Report on Facebook and X

Recent Posts

  • 4093 Wagner Road Sells for $630,000 in 2 Days, a Top-Tier Win for Sugarcreek Township
  • 10275 Cherry Tree Terrace Sells for $630,000, a Top-Tier Washington Township Sale
  • 4548 Royal Ridge Way Sells for $925,000, Ranking Third Among Kettering’s Sales
  • Game day: Miami men’s basketball hosts UIC, 12 p.m.
  • This week in Dayton college sports, November 22: 18 wins, 7 losses across 6 schools

News

  • Latest News
  • All Sections
  • Public Meetings
  • Zoning Alerts
  • Sports

Local Guides

  • Things to Do
  • This Weekend
  • Christmas Lights
  • Guides
  • Moving to Dayton
  • School Closings
  • Snow Emergencies
  • Rental Help
  • Food Pantries

Data and Maps

  • Dayton's Data
  • Home Sales
  • Look Up My Address
  • ZIP Code Map
  • Weather
  • Jobs
  • Free Tools

Shop and Community

  • Book Store
  • Church Finder
  • Business Directory
  • Add Your Business
  • Open Houses
  • Realtor Leaderboards

About

  • About
  • Newsletter
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • How We Report
  • Editorial Standards
  • Corrections
  • Privacy
  • RSS Feeds
  • Facebook
  • X
Get Dayton Report by EmailNew local stories, at most one email a day. Free.

©2026 Dayton Report | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme
Change Location
Find awesome listings near you!