Carlisle’s typical home sells near $290,000, and the top of the market is where a neighborhood shows its depth. A updated four-bedroom in Eagle Ridge 2 just closed at $460,000 after three weeks on the market, one of the area’s strongest results in the past 12 months.
A Carlisle Sale That Rises Well Above the Middle of the Market
Carlisle’s housing market tends to cluster in a recognizable range. Across the past 12 months, 67 homes sold in the area, and the median price came in at $289,900. Against that backdrop, a four-bedroom house in the Eagle Ridge 2 subdivision that closed at $460,000 stands a long way from the middle of the pack.
The home at 203 Quail Run Court closed on November 2, 2026, after 21 days on the market. It was listed at $465,000, so the final price landed $5,000 below ask, a difference of 1.1 percent. Among the 67 closed sales in Carlisle over the past year, this one ranks fourth, which places it inside the top 6 percent of the area’s results.
The house was built in 2007 and offers four bedrooms, 3.5 baths and 3,165 square feet of finished living space, a figure that includes the finished lower level. It has a covered front porch, an attached two-car garage and a fenced backyard with a patio. The listing describes a home that was refreshed throughout, from the kitchen to the bathrooms to the lighting, and the sale price suggests buyers in Carlisle’s upper range were paying attention to exactly that.
What follows is a close look at what the buyer got, how the price stacks up against the area’s medians, and how the closest recent sales compare. The short version: a larger, updated home in Eagle Ridge 2 found its buyer quickly, at a price that sits comfortably in the upper tier of the Carlisle market and at a lower cost per square foot than the area typically sees.
A 2007 Build With a Refreshed Kitchen and Interior
A house that is now about 19 years old sits in an interesting spot in the market. The structure is modern enough to avoid the major overhauls older homes need, but the finishes from that era can start to look dated. According to the listing, this home addressed that directly with a broad round of updates.
The kitchen is the centerpiece. It has quartz countertops, a tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances and new finishes that tie the room together. For many buyers touring homes in this price range, the kitchen is the first room that either confirms or undercuts the asking price, and a quartz-and-stainless kitchen with a clean backsplash gives a buyer little to fix before moving in.
The flooring was replaced throughout with new luxury vinyl plank and new carpet, which cuts down on one of the larger projects a buyer might otherwise price out after closing. Fresh paint covers the walls. Beyond the surfaces, the listing points to a long list of smaller details: new hardware, new plumbing fixtures, and new light fixtures, ceiling fans, outlets and switches. None of those items is dramatic on its own, but together they change how a house feels when someone walks in, and they remove the dozens of small to-do items that tend to pile up in a home that has not been touched in years.
A new sump pump rounds out the recent work. It is the kind of update that rarely makes a photo gallery but matters to anyone thinking about a finished lower level, since it supports the space that gives this house much of its square footage.
The result, as the listing frames it, is a move-in-ready home. In a market where the median home goes for $289,900, a buyer spending $460,000 is looking for a house that does not need work, and the interior updates are the main argument that this one delivers on that.
The Primary Suite and the Refreshed Baths
The primary suite is where the renovation work is most concentrated. The bathroom was renovated with a double vanity, a separate makeup vanity and a new ceramic tile shower with a glass door. A walk-in closet completes the suite and includes a built-in shoe rack, a small detail that signals the closet was thought through rather than simply left as an empty box.
A separate makeup vanity is a feature buyers often look for and rarely find outside of larger homes, and a double vanity paired with a tiled shower and glass door is the layout that tends to define a primary bath that feels current. In a house of 3,165 square feet, the suite gives the main living level a clear private retreat.
The remaining bathrooms were not skipped. The listing says all additional baths were refreshed with new vanities, fixtures, mirrors and lighting. With 3.5 baths across a four-bedroom layout, that matters: it means the updated look carries from one end of the house to the other instead of stopping at the primary suite. A buyer who sets up guests, a home office or a teenager’s bedroom is not walking into a bathroom that feels a decade behind the rest of the home.
That consistency is part of what separates a well-presented house from one that has simply had a few rooms updated for the photos. When the baths, kitchen, floors, paint and fixtures all move together, the home reads as one coherent project, and buyers tend to price it that way. In this case, they did: the home sold within 1.1 percent of its list price.
Finished Lower Level, Flexible Room and a Fenced Yard
A large share of the home’s 3,165 square feet comes from the finished lower level. The listing counts that space in the total, and it adds usable room beyond the main floors. Among the lower-level spaces is an additional room that the listing suggests could serve as a home office, workout room or playroom, or even as a fifth bedroom. The listing is candid that the room has no window or closet, so it works best as a flexible space rather than a conventional bedroom. That flexibility is useful on its own: a dedicated room for remote work or exercise is something many buyers now look for.
Outside, the property offers a fenced backyard with a patio, a storage shed and a basketball hoop. The fence matters for anyone with pets or small children, the patio gives the yard a defined spot for outdoor seating, and the shed takes lawn equipment and tools out of the garage. The hoop is a simple detail that suggests the yard was set up for everyday use.
At the front, a welcoming covered porch adds curb appeal and a place to sit, and the attached two-car garage handles parking and storage. For a suburban-style home in a subdivision setting, these are the features that tend to sit on a buyer’s checklist, and 203 Quail Run Court covers all of them.
Taken together, the lower level, the yard and the garage give the home room to flex across different stages of life. A household can use the finished basement as a playroom now and an office later, or turn the extra room into a workout space. That adaptability is a good part of why a four-bedroom, 3.5-bath home with more than 3,100 finished square feet can hold its value at a price well above the area median.
How $460,000 Compares With Carlisle’s 12-Month Numbers
The cleanest way to see the strength of this result is to put it next to the neighborhood figures. Over the past 12 months, Carlisle recorded 67 sales with a median price of $289,900. The sale at 203 Quail Run Court came in 59 percent above that median. In dollar terms, the buyer paid roughly $170,000 more than the typical Carlisle buyer, and the rank of 4 of 67 confirms this was no marginal outlier.
The price per square foot tells a second story. This home sold for $145 per square foot, while the area’s median sits at $181 per square foot. That is about 20 percent less per square foot than the typical Carlisle sale. The reason is size: at 3,165 square feet, the home offers far more finished space than the smaller houses that make up much of the market, and the extra square footage, including the finished lower level, brings the per-foot cost down even as the total price climbs. For buyers who need room, that is a meaningful trade.
Then there is the pace. The median home in Carlisle spent 24 days on the market over the past year. This one took 21 days, a little faster than typical, even though it sat in a much higher price bracket than most. Homes in the upper tier often take longer to find a buyer because the pool of qualified purchasers is smaller, so selling in three weeks at this level stands out.
Put the three measures together and the picture is consistent. The price was high relative to the area, the cost per square foot was low relative to the area, and the time on market was shorter than the median. A home that is expensive in total but sold quickly and at a reasonable per-foot cost suggests a well-matched price, and the buyer’s side of the table agreed.
The sale also sat just $5,000 under the $465,000 list price. A difference of 1.1 percent is narrow, and it indicates the asking price was set close to what the market was prepared to pay.
The Closest Comparable Sales
The best nearby comparison is a four-bedroom sale on Deep Woods Court, which closed at $400,000 on November 3, 2026, one day after 203 Quail Run Court. Both are four-bedroom homes, and both closed in the same week, which makes them useful side by side. The Quail Run Court sale came in $60,000, or about 15 percent, above it. The Deep Woods Court record does not list square footage, so a per-foot comparison is not possible, but the two sales together show that four-bedroom homes in the Carlisle area were trading in the $400,000 to $460,000 range in early November.
Other recent closings involve smaller homes. A three-bedroom on Arthur Avenue with 1,370 square feet sold for $269,900 on November 9, 2026, and a three-bedroom on Judy Avenue with 1,528 square feet sold for $250,000 on November 6, 2026. Both homes have less than half the finished space of the Quail Run Court property, and both sold well below its price.
Those smaller sales work out to about $197 per square foot on Arthur Avenue and about $164 per square foot on Judy Avenue. Both are higher per foot than the $145 paid at 203 Quail Run Court, which is typical: smaller homes usually carry a higher cost per square foot, and larger homes spread that cost across more space. For a buyer weighing the two paths, the Eagle Ridge 2 home offered roughly twice the finished area for about $190,000 to $210,000 more in total price.
The rest of the recent activity ran lower still. Two more three-bedroom sales, each on roughly 1,000 square feet, closed between $180,000 and $212,800. They illustrate how wide the Carlisle market is, from compact starter-sized homes in the low $200,000s to larger, updated homes above $400,000.
Looking at that spread, the 203 Quail Run Court sale lands at the upper end of what has traded recently, and it did so without lingering on the market. The cluster of closings in the first nine days of November also gives appraisers and agents a fresh set of data points for homes of different sizes.
What the Sale Means for Carlisle and Eagle Ridge 2
A median of $289,900 describes the center of the Carlisle market, but it does not capture the range. The upper tier, where a sale like this one lives, shows whether the area can support larger, updated homes at prices that reward owners for investing in them. With a rank of fourth among 67 sales in the past year, this result is evidence that it can.
For owners in Eagle Ridge 2 and similar subdivisions, the sale offers a data point worth noting. A 2007 home with refreshed kitchen, baths, flooring and fixtures, a finished lower level and a fenced yard drew a buyer in three weeks at $460,000. That does not set a rule for every house, but it shows what the market was willing to pay when a larger home was presented in move-in condition.
The result also helps buyers. At $145 per square foot, against a neighborhood median of $181, the home offered a lower cost per foot than most Carlisle sales, and a buyer who wanted four bedrooms, 3.5 baths and finished basement space could get them in one house. For households weighing smaller homes at higher per-foot prices against a larger home at a lower one, the numbers lay out the trade-off clearly.
Carlisle’s market is steady, and a sale like this one adds to it. One home does not change a market, but a quick close near full asking price, in the upper range, at a competitive price per foot, is the sort of result that gives sellers and buyers confidence in the next transaction on the block.
203 Quail Run Court sold on November 2, 2026 for $460,000. In a year of 67 Carlisle sales, only three finished higher.
Recognizing the Professionals Behind the Outcome
Listing agent Gary W Kurtz of Irongate Inc. brought the home to market, and Tyler Dietz of Keller Williams Seven Hills represented the buyer. Results like this come from careful pricing, strong presentation and steady work through closing, and both sides of the deal deserve recognition.
Listing data courtesy of Dayton REALTORS® MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
More Common Questions About Carlisle
These are the practical questions that come up most often about this sale and the Carlisle housing market.
How much did 203 Quail Run Court sell for?
The home sold for $460,000 on November 2, 2026. It was listed at $465,000, so it closed $5,000, or 1.1 percent, below the asking price, after 21 days on the market.
How does the sale price compare with a typical Carlisle home?
The median sale price in Carlisle over the past 12 months is $289,900 across 67 sales. At $460,000, this home sold 59 percent above that median and ranks fourth among the 67 sales.
What size is the home and what is the price per square foot?
The home has 3,165 square feet of finished living space, including the finished lower level, with four bedrooms and 3.5 baths. The sale works out to about $145 per square foot, compared with a Carlisle median of $181 per square foot.
How quickly did the home sell compared with the rest of the market?
It took 21 days to sell. The median for Carlisle over the past 12 months is 24 days, so this home sold a little faster than typical despite a price well above the median.
What updates did the home receive?
The listing describes quartz kitchen counters with a tile backsplash and stainless appliances, new luxury vinyl plank flooring and carpet, fresh paint, and new hardware, plumbing fixtures, lighting, ceiling fans, outlets and switches. The primary bath was renovated with a double vanity and a tiled shower with a glass door, the other baths were refreshed, and a new sump pump was installed.
How do nearby recent sales compare?
A four-bedroom home on Deep Woods Court sold for $400,000 on November 3, 2026. Three-bedroom homes on Arthur Avenue (1,370 square feet) and Judy Avenue (1,528 square feet) sold for $269,900 and $250,000 in early November, both with less than half the finished space of this home.
Follow Dayton Report: Facebook · X · Get the Dayton weekend email
