West Alexandria doesn’t make the headlines often—and that’s exactly why each home sale matters. With a population that hovers just over 1,300 and some of the most loyal residents in Preble County, this village thrives on stability, long-term ownership, and homes that rarely trade hands. So when a property of significance changes ownership, it stands out as a meaningful moment for the entire community. That’s the case with this recent sale on Fisher Twin Road, a beautifully crafted custom home situated on more than five acres—one of the most notable transactions West Alexandria has seen this year.
A Property That Represents the Best of Rural Preble County
The home itself is an impressive showcase of craftsmanship and intentional living. Originally constructed in 1973 but thoughtfully modernized, the residence offers nearly 6,000 square feet of living space, including five bedrooms, three-and-a-half bathrooms, and a long list of custom features rarely found in today’s new construction. From Brazilian hardwood floors and solid cherry cabinetry to Vermont wood stoves, a spa-style primary suite, and a finished walkout lower level perfect for multi-generational living, the property blends practicality with timeless detail.
Step inside and the home continues to impress. The living spaces are filled with natural light, wood trim, and high-quality finishes that speak to decades of care and investment.
The heart of the home is the custom kitchen, complete with solid cherry cabinetry, granite surfaces, and a seamless connection to the family room—perfect for gatherings, holidays, and daily life in a rural setting.
Outside, the estate offers everything Preble County buyers covet: fenced pastures, a 35×45 barn, a finished detached garage, a pond with a waterfall, an orchard, walking paths, a recreation-ready patio, and a hot tub overlooking the peaceful waters of Bantas Creek. Add the above-ground pool, standby generator, and solar panels, and the home becomes a fully self-supported rural retreat— the kind that rarely becomes available and often stays with the same family for generations.
Why This Sale Matters for West Alexandria
Unlike larger cities where hundreds of homes close each month, West Alexandria’s market is small, intimate, and heavily impacted by individual sales. When a standout property sells at the upper end of the market, it sends a strong signal about both the stability and desirability of the area.
This wasn’t just another rural home exchanging hands—this sale reinforces the value people place on the peace, space, and authenticity West Alexandria offers. It’s a benchmark-setting transaction that will likely play a role in future appraisals and comparable sales across the village.
Listing Agent Spotlight: Bill Thomas, Red 1 Realty
Representing a home of this scale requires a steady hand, strong communication, and a deep understanding of the rural Preble County buyer pool. Listing agent Bill Thomas of Red 1 Realty delivered exactly that.
Bill is known for going above and beyond for his clients—especially when working with unique rural properties that require more specialized marketing and buyer education. This successful sale is a testament to his consistency, professionalism, and ability to bring attention to homes that deserve it.
Insurance Reminder for Rural Homeowners
Homes with acreage, barns, generators, custom wood finishes, or solar setups have insurance needs that differ significantly from standard suburban properties. Ensuring the right coverage is essential—especially in rural areas where replacement costs and rebuild logistics can be very different.
For West Alexandria residents looking to review or update their coverage, Ingram Insurance’s West Alexandria page is an excellent starting point. Their team specializes in rural homes, farm-adjacent risks, and the unique structures commonly found throughout Preble County.
Closing Thoughts
This transaction marks another positive moment for West Alexandria—a community built on long-term residents, rural character, and deep pride in homeownership. The sale on Fisher Twin Road reflects all of that and more. Congratulations to the buyers, the sellers, and to Bill Thomas for a successful, community–strengthening sale.
For home, auto, farm, and rural property insurance in West Alexandria, contact Ingram Insurance:
Phone: (937) 741-5100
Website: www.insuredbyingram.com
Email: contact@insuredbyingram.com
