Rhonda Everitt is a licensed real estate agent with Comey & Shepherd REALTORS in Cincinnati, and a member of Dayton REALTORS®.
Recent Sales Activity
Over the past 12 months, MLS records show Rhonda on 12 closed sales (8 as the listing agent, 4 representing the buyer), about $5,221,800 in total sales volume. Most active in Mason, Lebanon, Loveland, Deerfield Township, Franklin and Miami Township.
Dayton Report Leaderboards
- 2nd in Mason (5 sales)
Overview
Rhonda Everitt is a real estate agent with Comey & Shepherd REALTORS, an independent brokerage that describes itself as having more than 76 years of experience. Her work in the past 12 months has centered on the Mason and Lebanon areas, with additional closings in Loveland, Deerfield Township, Franklin and Miami Township.
In that period she closed 12 sales with a combined volume of $5,221,800. Eight of those were listing-side transactions and four were on the buyer side, so about two-thirds of her closed business came from representing sellers.
She describes her focus as condos, townhomes and single-family homes, including properties with pools, and she cites experience with renovation projects on both older and newer houses. She also lists rightsizing, meaning moves to larger or smaller homes, as a specialty. Her own materials describe a service area that spans the Cincinnati and Dayton metro areas, and name Mason, Loveland and West Chester among the towns she works in.
Sales record in numbers
Across her 12 closed sales in the past 12 months, prices ranged from $249,900 to $629,900, with a median of $426,250. That spread covers entry-level and move-up price points, and the upper end reaches well into the range of larger single-family homes in southwest Ohio.
The strongest figures come from her listings. Of her 8 listing sales, the median time on the market was just 6.5 days. The median sale-to-list ratio was 100.0%, meaning the typical listing closed at its asking price. Five of the eight, or 5 of 8, sold at or above asking.
A quick sale at full price is a useful marker of pricing accuracy. Listings that go under contract within about a week and close at list suggest the opening price matched what buyers were prepared to pay. Her PSA (Pricing Strategy Advisor) designation, listed on her FastExpert profile, relates to that skill, though the designation itself says nothing about any particular sale.
The mix of properties also tells part of the story. About 42% of her closed sales were renovated homes, which fits her stated background in renovation work. None of her sales in the period were new construction, and none were multifamily properties. Her business was built on resale single-family homes and similar residential property.
Where she works
Mason accounted for the largest share of her business, with 5 closed sales at a median price of $520,000. The overall median sale price in Mason over the same period was $435,000, so her Mason work sat above the area midpoint. That places her activity in the upper-middle part of the local market.
Lebanon followed with 3 sales at a median of $460,000, compared with an area median of $370,000. Again, her closings were priced above the typical sale in the city. Together, Mason and Lebanon made up eight of her 12 closings.
The remaining four sales were spread across four other areas, one each:
In Loveland, she closed a sale at $249,900, below the area median of $390,000. This was also the low end of her overall price range. In Deerfield Township, her sale at $392,500 was close to the area median of $424,900. In Miami Township, her sale at $295,000 compared with an area median of $260,000. In Franklin, she closed a sale at $593,000, well above the area median of $260,000, and it sits near the top of her range.
Because the single-sale areas rest on one transaction each, they show breadth more than a pattern. What they do show is that she handles a wide band of prices, from under $250,000 to nearly $630,000, across several Butler, Warren and Hamilton County communities.
She recorded no sales in the city of Dayton or in West Dayton during the period. Her activity sits in the suburban communities north and east of Cincinnati and south of Dayton.
Background and credentials
Ohio real estate license number 2015004555 is associated with her name on her brokerage page and on agent directories.
Reports of her time in the business vary slightly. One agent directory lists 11 years, another lists 10, and her own website says nearly a decade. By any of those measures she has been licensed for roughly ten years.
Her listed designations include PSA (Pricing Strategy Advisor) and REALTOR, and her Homes.com profile notes membership in the National Association of Realtors. FastExpert, a third-party agent directory, names her a 2026 Five Star Agent and a 2026 Top Agent in Mason, Loveland and Maineville.
Her LinkedIn page, which she publishes herself and which the brokerage has not verified, lists several production honors. They include the Circle of Excellence from the Cincinnati Area Board of Realtors for 2019 through 2023, and recognition from the Realtor Alliance of Greater Cincinnati in January 2024. It also lists the Ohio Association of Realtors President’s Club in 2017 and 2018, and the Butler Warren Association Sales Master award in those same two years.
Before real estate, she says, she owned and managed four smoothie franchises. She also publishes a YouTube channel called Living in Cincinnati, Ohio, which she describes on her personal website. On her brokerage page she calls herself a top 5% agent with Comey & Shepherd, a self-description rather than a ranking we have verified.
How she compares locally
On the Dayton Report leaderboard for Mason, Everitt ranks third, with 5 closed sales in the past 12 months. Mason is the area where she is most active, and the ranking reflects a meaningful presence in a competitive suburban market.
Her numbers stand out in a few ways. Her listings sold in a median of 6.5 days, and the median listing sold at 100.0% of asking. Her median sale prices in Mason and Lebanon also sat above those of the surrounding markets, which indicates she works with homes in the middle and upper parts of those price ranges.
As with any single year of data, a dozen closings offer a snapshot rather than a full career record. The figures here describe the past 12 months of MLS activity and do not capture earlier years, which her listed honors suggest were productive.
For homeowners in Mason, Lebanon and nearby communities, her recent record shows a listing-focused practice with quick sales, pricing close to asking, and a notable share of renovated homes.
Leaderboard Badges
Rhonda can show this badge on a website, email or listing presentation. Each one updates itself with the current rank.
Get the code for this badge
Copy the code for a badge into your website’s HTML.
Mason (No. 2)
<a href="https://daytonreport.com/realtor-leaderboards/mason/" title="Dayton Report realtor leaderboard"><img src="https://daytonreport.com/badge/EVERRHON109/mason.svg" alt="No. 2 Realtor in Mason, Dayton Report 2026" width="240" height="80"></a>
Contact
Office phone: (937) 689-1013
Profile on the Comey & Shepherd REALTORS website
Sales figures come from Dayton REALTORS® MLS records and are updated monthly. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Is this you? Claim this listing to add your photo, bio and contact details.