Susan Andrews is a licensed real estate agent with New Home Star Ohio LLC in Southington, and a member of Dayton REALTORS®.
Recent Sales Activity
Over the past 12 months, MLS records show Susan on 8 closed sales (8 as the listing agent, 0 representing the buyer), about $3,386,695 in total sales volume. Most active in Cedarville Vlg, Beavercreek and Jamestown Vlg.
Dayton Report Leaderboards
- 1st in Cedarville Vlg (4 sales)
Overview
Susan Andrews works in new-home sales and is affiliated with New Home Star Ohio, LLC. All six were listing-side transactions, and every one was new construction.
Her work is concentrated in three Miami Valley communities: Beavercreek, Cedarville Village and Jamestown Village. In each of them her homes sold well above the area’s median price, which says something about the kind of product she handles: newly built homes in markets where much of the housing stock is older.
Her sales record in numbers
Andrews closed 6 sales in the period, all on the listing side (6 listing sides, 0 buyer sides). Together they total $2,512,695, an average of roughly $419,000 per home.
Prices ranged from a low of $378,000 to a high of $519,900, with a median of $390,000. The tight clustering of the lower prices, with most sales near the $380,000 to $390,000 mark, points to a fairly consistent product line, with one higher-priced sale at the top of the range.
On pricing, her listings closed at a median of 98.8% of list price. 3 of the 6 sold at or above asking. The median time on market for her listings was 160 days, a figure that is typical of new-construction homes, which are often marketed from the early stages of a build through completion.
The mix of sales is distinctive. 100% of her closed sales were new construction, and 67% were flagged as renovated in the MLS data. She recorded no multifamily sales and none in the City of Dayton or West Dayton, so her activity sits entirely in the eastern and southeastern parts of the region.
Where she works
Beavercreek is her largest market, with 3 sales. Her median price there was $444,895, compared with an area median of $325,000. That puts her Beavercreek closings about $120,000 above the typical sale in the community, consistent with newly built homes competing against a mix of older resale inventory.
Cedarville Village accounts for 2 sales, at a median of $383,950. The area median is $238,000, so her homes sold at a substantial premium to the village’s usual price point. In a smaller market like Cedarville, new construction stands out in a way it might not in a larger suburb.
Jamestown Village produced 1 sale, at $390,000, against an area median of $255,000. With a single transaction, the figure describes one home rather than a trend, but it matches the pattern in the other two areas.
Taken together, half of her closings were in Beavercreek and the other half in two small villages to its east. Those communities sit along the Greene County corridor, and they offer a different mix of lot sizes and housing ages than the denser neighborhoods closer to the center of Dayton.
Background and role
Public information describes Andrews as working on the builder side of the business. One professional page lists her as a Community Sales Manager for Better Life Homes of Columbus, with New Home Star Ohio, LLC named as the employer. Another directory entry lists her as a New Home Sales Specialist for Alogla Homes through New Home Star Corp, with a location in Springboro.
New Home Star describes itself as a new-home sales and marketing consulting firm that works with home builders. That sets it apart from a conventional residential brokerage: its agents typically represent a builder’s communities and inventory, which fits the all-listing, all-new-construction profile of her MLS record.
New Home Star Ohio, LLC is an active domestic limited liability company in Ohio. Its office is listed at 4550 Nelson Mosier Road in Southington, in the northeastern part of the state, and its listed service areas include Miami Township, Fairfax, Springboro, Liberty Township, Colerain Township and Lockland. Listings elsewhere in Ohio, including Centerburg and Reynoldsburg in the Columbus area, also carry her name with New Home Star, LLC, so her work extends beyond the Dayton market.
How the numbers read
Andrews’s record is a short one, covering only the period since March 2026, and it is best read as a snapshot of a new-construction practice. Six sales and about $2.5 million in volume is a modest total, but the per-home figures are strong: every area median she posted sat well above the local median for the community.
The days-on-market figure of 160 and the sale-to-list ratio of 98.8% are worth reading together. Homes that are sold before or during construction often carry long listing periods, yet half of hers closed at or above the asking price and the median closed within about one and a quarter percent of list.
No leaderboard positions are available for her in the Dayton market for this period, so no ranking comparisons are offered here. As more closings are recorded, the picture of her business in Beavercreek, Cedarville and Jamestown will become clearer, particularly whether the pricing and sale-to-list pattern holds across a larger number of homes.
Leaderboard Badges
Susan can show this badge on a website, email or listing presentation. Each one updates itself with the current rank.
Get the code for this badge
Copy the code for a badge into your website’s HTML.
Cedarville Vlg (No. 1)
<a href="https://daytonreport.com/realtor-leaderboards/cedarville-vlg/" title="Dayton Report realtor leaderboard"><img src="https://daytonreport.com/badge/ANDRESUSA109/cedarville-vlg.svg" alt="No. 1 Realtor in Cedarville Vlg, Dayton Report 2026" width="240" height="80"></a>
Contact
Office phone: (330) 240-4309
Sales figures come from Dayton REALTORS® MLS records and are updated monthly. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Is this you? Claim this listing to add your photo, bio and contact details.