Bart K Sheridan is a licensed real estate agent with Sheridans LLC in Cedarville, and a member of Dayton REALTORS®.
Recent Sales Activity
Over the past 12 months, MLS records show Bart on 24 closed sales (16 as the listing agent, 8 representing the buyer), about $8,956,751 in total sales volume. Most active in Xenia, Casstown, Cedarville Township, Cedarville Vlg, Jefferson Township and Waynesville.
Dayton Report Leaderboards
- 3rd in Cedarville Vlg (3 sales)
Overview
Bart K. Sheridan is a co-owner of Sheridans LLC, a family brokerage based at 200 Parkview Lane in Cedarville. The firm’s team page lists him as a real estate broker, auctioneer and appraiser, and he carries the Certified Auctioneers Institute (CAI) designation. According to the brokerage, he has been part of the business since 1995.
Over the past 12 months, MLS records show Sheridan closed 24 sales totaling $8,956,751. Sixteen of those were listings he represented sellers on, and eight were purchases he handled for buyers. Nearly all of the activity sits in Greene County and the communities around it, with Xenia, Casstown and Cedarville accounting for most of the closings.
His own profile describes a focus on real estate listings and auctions across southwest, central and western Ohio. The brokerage describes its work as spanning agricultural and rural farmland, residential and multifamily homes, building lots and commercial property. The sales figures that follow show how that range appears in his recent record.
The Sales Record in Numbers
Listings made up two-thirds of Sheridan’s closed business: 16 listing sides against 8 buyer sides. That balance points to a practice built mostly around bringing homes to market for sellers.
On those 16 listings, the median time on market was 26.5 days, and the median sale-to-list ratio was 100.0%, meaning the typical listing closed at its asking price. Ten of the 16 listings sold at or above asking.
Prices across his 24 closings ranged from $187,000 to $730,000, with a median of $300,000. That puts the middle of his business in the entry-to-mid range of the Greene County market, with a handful of sales well above it.
The mix of property types was largely resale housing. None of his closings in the period were new construction and none were multifamily. About 4% of his sales were renovated homes. He recorded no sales within the city of Dayton or in West Dayton during the window, which fits a practice centered east and southeast of the city.
Where He Works
Sheridan’s closings are spread across ten areas. Xenia led with 7 sales, followed by Casstown with 4. Cedarville Township and Cedarville Village each had 3, and Jefferson Township had 2. Single sales closed in Waynesville, Sugarcreek Township, Clayton, Xenia Township and Ross Township.
In Xenia, his median sale price was $321,000, compared with an area median of $250,000. That suggests his Xenia work skewed toward higher-priced homes than the typical sale there. In Casstown, his median of $285,000 sat close to the area median of $305,000.
Cedarville Township was an exact match: his median price and the area median were both $515,000. In Cedarville Village, his median was $235,000 against an area median of $256,000, a modest difference on three sales.
The largest gap came in Jefferson Township, where his two sales had a median of $525,000 against an area median of $183,340. In Sugarcreek Township, his single sale at $460,001 compared with an area median of $379,900. Smaller samples in Waynesville ($200,000 against a $425,000 area median) and Clayton ($187,000 against $275,000) reflect one sale each and say little on their own, though they show he works across a wide price spectrum.
Third-party profiles also list Fairborn, Springfield and Beavercreek among the areas where he is experienced, though those did not figure in his closings over the past year.
Background and Credentials
Sheridan earned a Bachelor of Accountancy degree from Miami University in 1989 and practiced as a certified public accountant in New Jersey and Ohio before turning to the family business. Published accounts say he began his career as an auctioneer and real estate broker in 1995, the year the brokerage’s history page says the eldest son joined the firm.
He earned the Certified Auctioneers Institute designation in 2001. In 2013, Gov. John Kasich appointed him to the Ohio Auctioneers Commission, where he served for four years. In 2019, the Ohio Auctioneers Association inducted him into its Hall of Fame, an honor recognizing his work in the auction profession, and the induction drew coverage in the agricultural press.
The brokerage says he is a licensed real estate broker and auctioneer. Listings associated with his name carry the line Courtesy of Bart K Sheridan and Sheridans LLC. A brokerage listing indicates he is a member of the National and Ohio Associations of Realtors and the Dayton Area Board of Realtors, and the firm participates in the WRIST MLS.
The company, formerly Sheridan & Associates, changed its name to Sheridans LLC in 2022. His brother Matt Sheridan is a co-owner, and Nathan Sheridan is another agent at the firm. Platform profiles list his specialties as investment sales and tenant representation, and the brokerage notes it serves clients throughout Ohio.
How He Compares Locally
In the Dayton Report’s local rankings, Sheridan places second in Cedarville Village, with 3 sales in the past 12 months. In a small village market, that puts him near the top of the agents active there.
Xenia was his largest market by count, with seven closings, and his pricing there ran above the area median. Elsewhere his results tracked area medians closely or reflected single transactions, so the broader picture is of an agent whose business is distributed across many communities rather than concentrated in one.
Taken together, the figures describe a listing-oriented practice with a median sale price of $300,000, listings that typically sell at asking price in under four weeks, and a footprint rooted in Greene County. Those local numbers sit alongside a background in auctions, accounting and farmland and rural property that the brokerage says is central to its work.
Leaderboard Badges
Bart can show this badge on a website, email or listing presentation. Each one updates itself with the current rank.
Get the code for this badge
Copy the code for a badge into your website’s HTML.
Cedarville Vlg (No. 3)
<a href="https://daytonreport.com/realtor-leaderboards/cedarville-vlg/" title="Dayton Report realtor leaderboard"><img src="https://daytonreport.com/badge/SHERIBARK109/cedarville-vlg.svg" alt="No. 3 Realtor in Cedarville Vlg, Dayton Report 2026" width="240" height="80"></a>
Contact
Office phone: (937) 766-2300
Profile on the Sheridans LLC website
Sales figures come from Dayton REALTORS® MLS records and are updated monthly. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Is this you? Claim this listing to add your photo, bio and contact details.